Differences between revisions 1 and 20 (spanning 19 versions)
Revision 1 as of 2014-10-27 20:16:36
Size: 1616
Editor: StephanOepen
Comment:
Revision 20 as of 2014-11-11 11:50:49
Size: 6263
Editor: StephanOepen
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 1: Line 1:
#acl StephanOepen:read,write,admin All:read #acl EsdGroup:read,write,admin All:read
Line 5: Line 5:
In collaboration with the Stanford University and the University of Washington, the WeSearch project at the University of Oslo holds a three-day, by-invitation working meeting from November 13 to 15, 2014, in Berlin. In collaboration with Stanford University and the University of Washington, the WeSearch project at the University of Oslo holds a three-day, by-invitation working meeting from November 13 to 15, 2014, in Berlin.
Line 12: Line 12:
= Materials =

Participants have been asked to prepare candidate analyses (or general, high-level reflections) for a
selection of some sixty [[http://svn.emmtee.net/trunk/uio/wesearch/ccs/berlin.txt|minimal exemplars]],
instantiating ten broad semantic phenomena.
The following representations are currently available for comparison:

 * [[http://svn.emmtee.net/trunk/uio/wesearch/ccs/amr/all.amr|Abstract Meaning Representation]] (AMR), with [[http://svn.emmtee.net/trunk/uio/wesearch/ccs/amr/notes.pdf|background notes]];
 * [[http://svn.emmtee.net/trunk/uio/wesearch/ccs/drs|Boxer Discourse Representation Structures]] (DRS), with [[http://svn.emmtee.net/trunk/uio/wesearch/ccs/drs/notes.pdf|background notes]];
 * [[http://svn.emmtee.net/trunk/uio/wesearch/ccs/erg/mrs.pdf|English Resource Semantics]] (ERS), with [[http://moin.delph-in.net/ErgSemantics/Ccs|background notes]];
 * [[http://svn.emmtee.net/trunk/uio/wesearch/ccs/fgd/fgd.pdf|Prague Functional Generative Descriptions]] (FGD), with [[http://ufal.mff.cuni.cz/functional-generative-description|background notes]]

Alex Lascarides has contributed a set of
[[http://svn.emmtee.net/trunk/uio/wesearch/ccs/lascarides.pdf|high-level reflections]], relating
compositional sentence semantics and desiderata originating in discourse-level analysis.
There is still room for additional target representations, reflections, or pointers to relevant literature.


= Schedule =

The meeting starts at 10:00 (‘after breakfast’) on Thursday, November 13, and we will wrap up
around 16:00 on Saturday, November 15.
The plan is to use the first session to ‘jump right in’, i.e. familiarize ourselves with the
various representations and discuss design choices for a specific phenomenon, control relations
(which we believe to be relatively well-understood and comparatively uncontroversial).

Reflecting on this first joint calibration session, we plan on a brief high-level discussion after lunch,
to exchange views about, for example, our specific goals in different approaches to meaning
representation (and composition), known or anticipated commonalities and differences, notions
of standing (or sentence) vs. occassion (or speaker) meaning, the role of grammar, or which
sub-tasks to differentiate in semantic analysis (like, for example, predicate–argument analysis,
sense disambiguation, named entity classification, resolving scope ambiguities, and
coreference resolution).

To prepare for an afternoon coffee break, we will not let theoretical arguments get out of
hand and start discussing a second phenomenon in that same session.
From there on, the meeting agenda is largely up to collective decision making, but we shall
try to get through in-depth discussion of at least six of the phenomena on our shopping list.

|||| '''Thursday, November 13''' ||
|| 10:00–12:30 || Control Relations (Calibration) ||
|| 12:30–13:30 || Lunch ||
|| 13:30–14:30 || High-Level Goals ||
|| 14:30–15:30 || Clausal Complements ||
|| 15:30–16:00 || Coffee ||
|| 16:00–18:00 || Clausal Complements ||
|||| '''Friday, November 14''' ||
|| 09:00–10:30 || Third Phenomenon ||
|| 10:30–11:00 || Coffee ||
|| 11:00–12:30 || Third Phenomenon ||
|| 12:30–13:30 || Lunch ||
|| 13:30–15:30 || Fourth Phenomenon ||
|| 15:30–16:00 || Coffee ||
|| 16:00–17:30 || Fourth Phenomenon ||
|| 19:30 || Joint Dinner ||
|||| '''Saturday, November 15''' ||
|| 09:00–10:30 || Fifth Phenomenon ||
|| 10:30–11:00 || Coffee ||
|| 11:00–12:30 || Fifth Phenomenon ||
|| 12:30–13:30 || Lunch ||
|| 13:30–15:30 || Sixth Phenomenon ||
|| 15:30–16:00 || Collective Wrap-Up ||

All scheduled sessions will meet in Business Suite 616 on the top floor of the hotel.
Coffee breaks are not served at the hotel, but there are at least two decent coffee
shops in the immediate neighborhood.


= Participants =

 * Emily M. Bender, University of Washington (Wednesday to Monday)
 * Johan Bos, University of Groningen (Wednesday to Saturday)
 * Silvie Cinkova, Charles University of Prague (Wednesday to Sunday)
 * Cleo Condoravdi, Stanford University
 * Ann Copestake, University of Cambridge (Wednesday to Saturday)
 * Dick Crouch, Nuance Communications (Wednesday to Sunday)
 * Dan Flickinger, Stanford University (Wednesday to Monday)
 * Jan Hajič, Charles University of Prague (Saturday)
 * Alexander Koller, Potsdam University
 * Alex Lascarides, University of Edinburgh (Wednesday to Sunday)
 * Stephan Oepen, University of Oslo (Wednesday to Sunday)
 * Martha Palmer, University of Colorado Boulder
 * Tim O'Gorman, University of Colorado Boulder (Wednesday to Saturday)
 * Woodley Packard, University of Washington (Wednesday to Monday)

Line 17: Line 103:
 * travel costs, up to EUR 300 or EUR 800 for European or US participants, respectively;  * travel costs, up to EUR 300 or EUR 800 for European or US participants, respectively;
Line 22: Line 108:
Participants are asked to make their own travel arrangements and email their arrival and departure times to StephanOepen.
Please keep receipts and (if applicable) boarding passes, which you will have to submit for reimbursement to the University of Oslo after completion of your travels.  With a bit of luck, reimbursements should be processed by mid-December.


= Schedule =

We plan on starting the meeting
at 10:00 (‘after breakfast’) on Thursday, November 13, and wrap up
around 16:00 on Saturday, November 15.
Participants are asked to make their own travel arrangements and email their arrival
and departure times to StephanOepen, who will make hotel reservations.
Please keep receipts and (if applicable) boarding passes, which you will have to submit
for reimbursement to the University of Oslo after completion of your travels.
With a bit of luck, reimbursements should be processed by mid-December.

Comparative Computational Semantics

In collaboration with Stanford University and the University of Washington, the WeSearch project at the University of Oslo holds a three-day, by-invitation working meeting from November 13 to 15, 2014, in Berlin. The meeting will be hosted at Arcotel Velvet, not far away from Bahnhof Friedrichstraße, which is easily accessible from both airports.

Materials

Participants have been asked to prepare candidate analyses (or general, high-level reflections) for a selection of some sixty minimal exemplars, instantiating ten broad semantic phenomena. The following representations are currently available for comparison:

Alex Lascarides has contributed a set of high-level reflections, relating compositional sentence semantics and desiderata originating in discourse-level analysis. There is still room for additional target representations, reflections, or pointers to relevant literature.

Schedule

The meeting starts at 10:00 (‘after breakfast’) on Thursday, November 13, and we will wrap up around 16:00 on Saturday, November 15. The plan is to use the first session to ‘jump right in’, i.e. familiarize ourselves with the various representations and discuss design choices for a specific phenomenon, control relations (which we believe to be relatively well-understood and comparatively uncontroversial).

Reflecting on this first joint calibration session, we plan on a brief high-level discussion after lunch, to exchange views about, for example, our specific goals in different approaches to meaning representation (and composition), known or anticipated commonalities and differences, notions of standing (or sentence) vs. occassion (or speaker) meaning, the role of grammar, or which sub-tasks to differentiate in semantic analysis (like, for example, predicate–argument analysis, sense disambiguation, named entity classification, resolving scope ambiguities, and coreference resolution).

To prepare for an afternoon coffee break, we will not let theoretical arguments get out of hand and start discussing a second phenomenon in that same session. From there on, the meeting agenda is largely up to collective decision making, but we shall try to get through in-depth discussion of at least six of the phenomena on our shopping list.

Thursday, November 13

10:00–12:30

Control Relations (Calibration)

12:30–13:30

Lunch

13:30–14:30

High-Level Goals

14:30–15:30

Clausal Complements

15:30–16:00

Coffee

16:00–18:00

Clausal Complements

Friday, November 14

09:00–10:30

Third Phenomenon

10:30–11:00

Coffee

11:00–12:30

Third Phenomenon

12:30–13:30

Lunch

13:30–15:30

Fourth Phenomenon

15:30–16:00

Coffee

16:00–17:30

Fourth Phenomenon

19:30

Joint Dinner

Saturday, November 15

09:00–10:30

Fifth Phenomenon

10:30–11:00

Coffee

11:00–12:30

Fifth Phenomenon

12:30–13:30

Lunch

13:30–15:30

Sixth Phenomenon

15:30–16:00

Collective Wrap-Up

All scheduled sessions will meet in Business Suite 616 on the top floor of the hotel. Coffee breaks are not served at the hotel, but there are at least two decent coffee shops in the immediate neighborhood.

Participants

  • Emily M. Bender, University of Washington (Wednesday to Monday)
  • Johan Bos, University of Groningen (Wednesday to Saturday)
  • Silvie Cinkova, Charles University of Prague (Wednesday to Sunday)
  • Cleo Condoravdi, Stanford University
  • Ann Copestake, University of Cambridge (Wednesday to Saturday)
  • Dick Crouch, Nuance Communications (Wednesday to Sunday)
  • Dan Flickinger, Stanford University (Wednesday to Monday)
  • Jan Hajič, Charles University of Prague (Saturday)
  • Alexander Koller, Potsdam University
  • Alex Lascarides, University of Edinburgh (Wednesday to Sunday)
  • Stephan Oepen, University of Oslo (Wednesday to Sunday)
  • Martha Palmer, University of Colorado Boulder
  • Tim O'Gorman, University of Colorado Boulder (Wednesday to Saturday)
  • Woodley Packard, University of Washington (Wednesday to Monday)

Financial Support

The project has available funds by the Norwegian Research council to cover (the bulk of) expenses related to participation in the meeting, viz.

  • travel costs, up to EUR 300 or EUR 800 for European or US participants, respectively;
  • up to four overnight stays at the conference hotel (not including breakfast);
  • lunches during the three days of the working meeting (Thursday to Saturday);
  • a joint dinner for all participants, on Friday evening (November 14).

Participants are asked to make their own travel arrangements and email their arrival and departure times to StephanOepen, who will make hotel reservations. Please keep receipts and (if applicable) boarding passes, which you will have to submit for reimbursement to the University of Oslo after completion of your travels. With a bit of luck, reimbursements should be processed by mid-December.

WeSearch/Ccs (last edited 2014-11-19 23:02:45 by EmilyBender)

(The DELPH-IN infrastructure is hosted at the University of Oslo)