Added a small comparison with CLIM
|Deletions are marked like this.||Additions are marked like this.|
|Line 21:||Line 21:|
|Line 161:||Line 163:|
= Comparison with CLIM =
* Interactive unification is easier with LUI (drg and drop)
* LUI currently lacks the following functionality
* Show Hierarchy
* Show Generation Chart
* Parse Input Window
The Linguistic User Interface (LUI) is an on-going project to build a visualization tool for the most common object types in constraint-based grammars, i.e. trees, feature structures, MRSs, charts, et al. While the LKB comes with built-in browsers for all of these, the current use of the CLIM (Common-Lisp Interface Manager) toolkit in the LKB severely limits portability and ease of use (and programmatic extension). Thus, portability and royalty-free delivery are among the primary motivations for the LUI project; at the same time, LUI attempts to `conservatively' improve over the existing LKB tools, for example in terms of layout options, scalability, user parameterization, display effiency. While preserving all existing LKB display functionality, LUI adds some new facilities, including drag-and-drop interactive unification, display of, and navigation through multiple feature structure incompatibilities, and creation of screen dumps in (for now) PostScript or LaTeX formats.
The standard implementation of LUI is an application of the [http://yz-windows.sourceforge.net/ YZ Windows] API, developed mainly by WoodleyPackard, who is also the main LUI developer (with LKB-side support by StephanOepen). An alternate LUI binary compiled with Pango (which gives better font support for various international character sets) is available (albeit in binary only) as part of [wiki:LkbTrollet Trollet], developed by PavelMihaylov; see below.
Existing LUI Browsers
LUI currently provides browsers for four types of linguistic structures, viz. constituent trees (LuiTree), feature structures (LuiAvm), MRSs (LuiMrs), and parse charts (LuiChart). For other types of linguistic objects, a LUI-enabled LKB session will just fall back on the default, built-in display methods from the LKB.
LUI browsers exhibit certain common interface characteristics, described on the LuiUi page.
Obtaining and Running LUI
Recent LUI binaries for Linux (x86 in 32- and 64-bit mode) and Mac OS X are part of the LinGO LKB CVS repository. As of August 2005, LUI support is also included in LKB binary builds (see the LkbInstallation pages). During an initial testing phase, LUI support is not turned on by default. There are multiple ways of activating LUI, e.g. (a) manually within a running LKB session, (b) from within the `.lkbrc' user-specific LKB configuration file, or (c) by means of a shell environment variable. You can customize LUI by means of a per-user .luirc file (LuiRc).
Activating (or Deactivating) LUI Support
To enable LUI during an LKB session, at the Common-Lisp prompt evaluate the command
Activating LUI for a running LKB session means switching graphical display to LUI widgets for the supported types of linguistic objects (see above). Once LUI has been initialized, parse trees, AVMs, et al. should all be displayed using LUI widgets.
Conversely, to disable LUI for the current LKB session, evaluate
For debugging purposes or comparison to the LKB built-in display (on platforms that support built-in graphics for the LKB), it is possible to toggle between LUI-enabled mode and no-LUI mode frequently within a single session.
Turning on LUI by Default
One option for requesting LUI activation at LKB start-up is to place a call to lui-initialize() (see above) into the file .lkbrc in a user home directory. The .lkbrc file is a user-specific configuration file that is read when the LKB starts up.
The recommended option, however, is to set (and export) a shell variable LUI to a positive value, e.g. (in your user-specific .bashrc file):
Note that for shells other than bash(1) (or the MacOS environment), the syntax of setting environment variables may differ. Finally, setting the value of the LUI environment variable to a positive integer will cause the LKB to activate LUI support but wait for an external (typically remote) LUI to connect to the port named by its numeric value (see below).
Alternate LUI Implementations
The LUI design foresees the option of having alternate implementation of the LUI functionality and protocol. For exampke, PavelMihaylov has adapted the original LUI source code to use the [http://wiki.delph-in.net/moin/LkbLui?action=edit Pango] font rendering engine, for better international character support. Each alternate implementation should define its own application name, say pangolui instead of yzlui. Accordingly, the 'pangolui' binary should read the user configuration files .pangoluirc and .luirc (and a corresponding file name for its log file). The general idea here is to put configuration options that are specific to a token LUI implementation into .yzluirc or .pangoluirc (for example font selection commands), and use the general .luirc for configuration options that should apply to any LUI implementation.
Although as of February 2008 no source code is availabe, Pavel distributes [http://lingua.bash.info/trollet/ alternate LUI binaries] for Linx (x86, 32- and 64-bit). Currently, these binaries do not yet define their own application name, thus (somewhat sloppily) read .yzluirc (rather than .pangoluirc) and .luirc. The recommended way of installing these binaries is as pangolui in the platform-specific binary directory of the LKB tree, for example lkb/bin/linux.x86.32/ on a 32-bit, Linux (x86) installation. To activate an alternate binary, use the LUI shell variable, e.g.
One can also specify the binary name when you (re)start the lui:
(lui-initialize :lui "pangolui")
Note One cannot specify an absolute path using either method, only the binary name. Hence, alternate LUI binaries need to be installed into the correct, platform-specific LKB binary directory.
LUI Remote Mode
LUI can also run in remote mode, communicating with an LKB session on a different machine. This mode of operation may be attractive for people running the LKB (or, in principle, another linguistic processor with LUI support) across a network with noticeable latency; the YZ widget library is somewhat more sensitive to network latency than, say, X11. First, the LKB host must be told to accept connections. This is accomplished by a command like:
(lui-initialize :port 4001)
Then, LUI must be launched with a special command line option. The executable lives in the lkb/bin/linux.x86.32/yzlui location inside the DELPH-IN top-level source directory (for Linux, x86, 32-bit) or the bin/macos.ppc.32/yzlui.app/Contents/MacOS/yzlui location for Mac OS X. A remote connection is established by launching a LUI process (manually) from a shell, and directing it to talk to a running LKB session and the numeric port used as the argument to the lui-initialize() call. Assumming the LKB session runs on host cypriot.stanford.edu, say, the following might work:
$DELPHINHOME/lkb/bin/linux.x86.32/yzlui -c cypriot.stanford.edu:4001
Testing and Bug Reporting
The first public LUI release is in August 2005. For a few months prior to the release date, the new tools have only been tested by one active LKB grammarian (our thanks go to DanFlickinger). Unexpected behavior may comprise a bug. LUI maintains a log file describing your session in the file /tmp/yzlui.debug.username (where username corresponds to your own user id). Please report bugs to the DELPH-IN developers mailing list and always attach a corresponding LUI log file from the `/tmp/' directory.
Please add wishlist requests to LuiWishlist.
LUI Documentation at a Glance
Comparison with CLIM
- Interactive unification is easier with LUI (drg and drop)
- LUI currently lacks the following functionality
- Show Hierarchy
- Show Generation Chart
- Parse Input Window